Star Wars: Obi-Wan Kenobi 1×05, the evaluation of the penultimate episode on Disney +

The evaluation of the penultimate episode of Star Wars: Obi-Wan Kenobi 1×05, the sequence on Disney+ the place our Jedi struggles previous and current.

At this level, it is fairly clear that there have been points within the making of Obi-Wan Kenobi. Bottlenecks could have been brought on by the pandemic, amongst different issues, which have turn into more and more obvious over the weeks, particularly because it has nearly turn into a recreation to trace down the defects of the brand new TV sequence on Disney + giving up any pretense of leisure. Subsequent week we’ll strive to consider the season in its entirety whereas we discuss concerning the last episode, however for now we’ve to confess that there has actually been much more carelessness than in a manufacturing like The Mandalorianand most stunning is the truth that Obi-Wan Kenobi is centered round an iconic character, a lot cherished and likewise performed by a unprecedented actor, additionally as a producer.

The alternating execs and cons in every episode, as we mentioned final week, is…irritating. This penultimate date on paper would have been nice general, had been it not for some controversial features that undermine the present generally. Let’s have a look at them collectively in ours Obi-Wan Kenobi 1×05 Assessment and, as standard, watch out as our evaluation will essentially want some spoilers.

Masters and Padawans

Obi-Wan Kenobi, a flashback to the time of Episode II

Star Wars followers will certainly respect the flashbacks within the episode and convey them again to the scene Hayden Christensen as Anakin Skywalker throughout Episode II, within the scenes the place Vader recollects a coaching session, and Episode III, which reinterprets the bloodbath on the Jedi Temple. For what little may be seen, Christensen managed to convey Anakin’s tone and swagger twenty years later, however we will not blame anybody for noticing the wrinkles within the coaching scene—within the different flashbacks, Anakin holds up his hood and the face at midnight. gentle – as Lucasfilm might have resorted to pc graphics as completed in The Mandalorian with Mark Hamill’s Luke Skywalker. Admittedly, Christensen is carrying his age effectively, however that Anakin is certainly older than the identical character we met in Assault of the Clones.

That mentioned, see Grasp and Padawan face off in duelEven when just for coaching, it was numerous enjoyable, not least as a result of it served to remind essentially the most forgetful of viewers what sort of Anakin was. We should always not overlook that along with the prequel films, there have been a number of seasons of Star Wars: The Clone Wars which have labored on the character and at this level it appears acceptable to emphasise how a lot the Star Wars TV sequence attracts from that imaginary .

The connection between Maestro and Padawan is a central theme on this episode, but additionally defining in a number of methods, even when it must be higher defined to the director of the Italian dubbing, who was in a position to authorize one blunder monumental when Reva, turning to Obi-Wan and referring to Anakin, exclaims, “You had been his Padawan!”. In fact the unique line is “He was your Padawan” and the Italian subtitles are right so it is actually a dubbing error.

However let’s speak about this reva, a lot taunted on-line and in actual life. On the identical pages, we have repeatedly complained about her flatness as an antagonist, to the detriment of Moses Ingram’s appearing credentials, however we actually do not share the racial slurs that overwhelmed her. Episode 5 considerably fixes the flawed characterization of the third sister lastly clarify the explanations. Which had been additionally fairly clear – for instance all of us obtained that from the primary episode? — and never totally convincing, however in context they work and no less than justify his anger and his strategies. Now will probably be crucial to grasp which route the character will go, particularly whether it is true that Disney + is evaluating a miniseries aimed toward her.

Obi-Wan Kenobi, look who's back!
Obi-Wan Kenobi, look who’s again!

The issue is that the subplot was confused from the beginning with a sequence of questionable methods that in the end appeared inconclusive to us as effectively, beginning with the loss of life of the grand inquisitorwhich we have been puzzling over for weeks – the Pau’an will nonetheless be alive and effectively in Star Wars: Rebels years later – and which turned out to be in essentially the most mundane means of all, as Reva was Grand Inquisitor for lower than 30 years. minutes.

Path issues

Obi-Wan Kenobi, Darth Vader is getting more and more powerful
Obi-Wan Kenobi, Darth Vader is getting increasingly highly effective

There’s yet one more grasp we must be speaking about, and it isn’t Obi-Wan who on this episode, unusual to say, does little or no besides give recommendation and examine a careless technique that solely finally ends up working as a result of the script wished it to. . In the true world, nobody would have made half of the selections on this episode, however we wish to reiterate: Star Wars isn’t the true world. It is household fiction. Leisure for everybody. The authors need inform a narrative which, furthermore, falls inside sure exact canons and is all the time projected upon the victory of the forces of fine and hope. Anticipating mutilation, blood and visible or verbal abuse is totally pointless. If that is what you are searching for, I am sorry to say that you do not perceive what Star Wars is.

All these complaints concerning the child too Leia, on Disney who wish to promote Star Wars to children, they depart the time they discover. One title: Jar-Jar Binks. Film: The Phantom Menace. It was the early 2000s and George Lucas nonetheless had Star Wars. And it isn’t as if his trilogies had been stuffed with blood and guts.

Obi-Wan Kenobi, who cut NED-B and Tala's subplot?
Obi-Wan Kenobi, who minimize NED-B and Tala’s subplot?

That mentioned, it is clear that the manufacturing has tried to lift the bar to “promote” one. Darth Vader extra menacing within the flesh than we have recognized within the unique trilogy. We have seen Vader on different events – for instance in Rogue One and in Star Wars: Rebels – and Lucasfilm has continued to rework him right into a power of nature, when within the Lucas movies he was truly an excellent warrior and that was it. Chapter 5 of Obi-Wan Kenobi overcomes the carnage of some weeks in the past with a duel wherein we see Vader combating with the sheer energy of fan service, deflecting the lightsaber blows and parrying with the Pressure, with out even wielding his iconic weapon. sting a lot of the time.

It might be a terrific second if it weren’t toned down by clumsy choreography and really flat route. By now it must be clear to everybody that Obi-Wan Kenobi’s large drawback is simply that: the route† Not a lot the finances or the post-production, which can have been crippled by the well being restrictions, though at this level it might have been higher to postpone the sequence as completed with Andor or Ms. Marvel.

Obi-Wan Kenobi, next week it's back to Tatooine
Obi-Wan Kenobi, subsequent week it is again to Tatooine

There are moments within the episode which have big potential however endure from technical points such because the misuse of the shaky room, unsatisfactory lighting, a monotonous and uncreative route. The duel we talked about is a shining instance, but additionally the scene that precedes it and which reminded us of the online game Star Wars: The Energy of the Pressure, has the power to leap begin, the viewer titillating after which making him snigger loudly, with a relatively ridiculous narrative facet that will have been sufficient to disguise with a greater job within the recordings.

The identical may be mentioned of the introspective second dedicated to tala: It is a very nice scene, however you’ve got the clear feeling that one thing is lacking, that possibly the sequence hasn’t explored its relationship with the NED-B droid sufficient, or that there hasn’t been higher coordination between director and writers.


Obi-Wan Kenobi stays a problematic TV sequence, however ultimately all of it is determined by the sensitivity of the person viewer and the load given to it. We’ve to confess that our crucial minds have come to search out them increasingly over the weeks, maybe as a result of all that speak about them has lastly ready us to search for technical flaws, which can be roughly apparent. To be clear, Obi-Wan Kenobi 1×05 is a superb episode, however we will not assist however suppose that within the fingers of a extra succesful director, and maybe in a easier time, it might have been much more.


  • the flashbacks
  • Darth Vader Unleashed


  • The absurd misstep in Italian dubbing
  • A weak route that belittles the perfect scenes

Leave a Comment